Review registry
Editorial review and independent review are different.
An outside review appears only when the reviewer, qualification, scope, conflict disclosure, exact version, decision, and independently controlled verification are visible.
No outside review has passed the publication gate.
AI Amigos editorial checks remain visible as internal review and are never relabeled as independent validation.
Propose an external reviewIndependent review requires
- Named reviewer and relevant qualification
- Exact method or report version
- Bounded review scope and decision
- Conflict and compensation disclosure
- Outside verification link
Reviewer independence is limited when
- The reviewer created the work
- The reviewer reports to the author
- Compensation is undisclosed
- The reviewed version is unclear
- The statement is hosted only by AI Amigos